Within the seismic play (and subsequent tv mini-series) Angels in America, two males on opposites of political ideology fall right into a harmful type of love, all whereas the specter of Roy Cohn looms over them. That play, set within the terrible clench of Reagan and AIDS, is haunted by older issues—Bolshevik revolution, pogroms, and the federal government purges of Fifties McCarthyism. The brand new mini-series Fellow Vacationers (Showtime, October 29) brings the latter period to the foreground, as two males start an affair whereas perilously near, properly, the sinister ministrations of Roy Cohn.
The collection is predicated on the novel by Thomas Mallon, which spans many years however principally stays zoomed in on the scary persecutions of Joseph McCarthy. Hawkins Fuller (Matt Bomer) is a suave, good-looking, war-hero Washington wheel-greaser, an eligible bachelor who prefers to spend his non-public time having tough intercourse (he’s all the time the dom) with males he meets at homosexual speakeasies and different cruising spots. He’s fairly good at dwelling a secret life, although after all a certain quantity of recklessness is all the time in play.
Hawk is an efficient sufficient mentor to wide-eyed Tim Laughlin (Jonathan Bailey), a devoutly Catholic rube from the Midwest who wholeheartedly helps anti-Communist efforts and, by means of Hawk’s assist, finds himself working for McCarthy. As their profession positions develop ever extra compromised, the 2 males start a lusty, push-and-pull affair; Hawk is the pragmatic, emotionally distant foil to Tim’s earnest longing. Although we watch as Hawk and Tim transfer from the furtively carnal towards one thing like a real relationship, the present’s multiple-timeline gadget tells us fairly early on that this relationship doesn’t endure. Within the Eighties, Hawk is in a protracted marriage to a senator’s daughter whereas Tim is dying of AIDS in San Francisco.
Fellow Vacationers is a weepy, a star-crossed love story about individuals torn asunder by forces political and private, by disgrace and worry and stubbornness. Because the collection unfolds, the intriguing Washingtonian-thriller trappings of early episodes—notes covertly handed, betrayals completed out of ruthless self-preservation—give solution to extra acquainted, plodding melodrama. Creator Ron Nyswaner expands the scope of the story past that of the novel, reaching to include a complete historical past of homosexual wrestle because the motion lurches its solution to the progresses of the Nineteen Nineties and 2000s, amidst the bitter devastation of a plague.
Worthy as these matters are, they really feel tacked onto what may in any other case be a shrewd, unhappy story of head and coronary heart at warfare throughout a charged American second, a kind of homosexual Graham Greene story. Had Fellow Vacationers not felt the urge to coax the best received tears out of its viewers, its characters might need maintained extra specificity, extra intricate depth. As an alternative the collection regularly flattens these males into clichés: Hawk is the tragic old-schooler who solely accepts himself when it’s too late, Tim the youthful idealist who turns into a martyr to the trigger. We come to bitterly miss the chilly savvy of the collection’s starting, the moody mid-century air of suspense and high-wire discretion.
What’s fixed all through is the intercourse, which Fellow Vacationers presents in blunt abundance. A transparent energy dynamic is established within the many scenes of Hawk and Tim within the warmth of ardour—one which must be extra palpable within the scenes wherein they’re clothed. Different lovers enter the image, significantly throughout a fraught expedition to Seventies Fireplace Island, however Hawk and Tim are on the white scorching middle of the present’s depiction of homosexual male sexuality. (Which entails a maybe anachronistic quantity of pecs and abs.) It’s appreciated that the present goes there, however these scenes additionally act in unusual discord with the mushier, blander features of the collection. The present clearly needs to confront the viewers with one thing actual and visceral, however then it swings wildly again to broad sentimentalism and didactic point-making.
It’s an imbalanced collection, one making an attempt to do an excessive amount of without delay. The present makes an attempt to diversify its purview by introducing a facet plot involving an formidable Black reporter, Marcus (Jelani Alladin), contending with D.C. racism and a few of his personal femme-phobia as he falls for a drag performer, Frankie (Noah J. Ricketts). That’s an attention-grabbing story to inform, however can solely get a lot consideration when Hawk and Tim are occupying many of the narrative house. Equally, Hawk’s spouse, Lucy (Allison Williams), is given focus towards the tip of the collection, however that appears like too little too late—if she was going to be a significant participant within the story, her perspective wanted to be launched sooner.
All of the actors concerned do their greatest to flesh out what the writing doesn’t. Bomer is especially hanging, utilizing his matinee-idol seems to each seduce and repulse. He’s slickly convincing as a shifty political operator, even when he has to say clunky traces like, “Seems like I lastly have a date with Mr. Proper. Or ought to I say, Mr. Proper Wing.” Bailey is tasked with mapping Tim’s shift from dutiful conservative to lefty radical, ceaselessly contending along with his compromised religion. The writing renders Tim too good, too besotten, too unquestionably good to be a very attention-grabbing character, however Bailey at the very least sells the sweetness of old flame and the harm of its ending. (Which occurs many times as Fellow Vacationers journeys ahead and backward by means of time.)